Holiday Gifts2 min read

What is a Dirty Santa gift everyone will try to steal?

The Snapshot TeamMakers of custom trading cardsLast reviewed:
Party guests in Christmas sweaters fighting over a custom trading card during a Dirty Santa game
5.0on Google

Quick answer

Bring a custom trading card of someone everyone at the party knows: the host, the uncle who wins every year, the office dog. Put ridiculous stats on the back, like "Gifts stolen: 37. Gifts given back: 0", and watch it change hands all night. It costs $17.99 and comes in a magnetic display case.

Key takeaways

  1. Dirty Santa is white elephant with more stealing: same rules, louder room.
  2. The gift that gets stolen most is about someone at the party, not a store-bought gag.
  3. Write the back like a rap sheet: "Gifts stolen: 37. Gifts given back: 0."
  4. One card is $17.99 in a magnetic display case; a slab is $39.99 for a card that looks too valuable to give up.

Dirty Santa in thirty seconds

Everyone brings one wrapped gift and draws a number. On your turn, open a new gift or steal one that is already open. Get robbed and you open another or steal from someone else. Most groups agree that a gift is frozen after two or three steals, so the last thief keeps it.

It is the same game as white elephant and Yankee Swap. Dirty Santa is the name for the version where the stealing gets personal.

Why a card of someone in the room wins

A gag gift gets one laugh, and then nobody wants the singing fish. A trading card of the host, with a straight face on the front and a rap sheet on the back, gets a laugh when it is opened and a fight every time it is stolen, because there is exactly one of it.

It also outlives the party. It is printed on real card stock and sits in a magnetic display case, so it ends up on a desk or the fridge instead of in the regift pile.

Stat lines for maximum chaos

The back of the card is where the trash talk lives:

  • The host: "Parties hosted: 11. Parties that started on time: 0"
  • The reigning champion: "Dirty Santa titles: 6. Times accused of cheating: 6"
  • The coworker: "Reply-alls sent: 1,204. Regrets: none"
  • The dog: "Presents unwrapped early: all of them"
  • Grandpa: "Thermostat changes this season: 41. Permission asked: 0"

Going over the top

If your group plays for blood, raise the stakes:

  • Put the card in a slab for $39.99, so it looks like it belongs in a vault. Nobody gives up a slabbed card without a fight.
  • Make it holographic. A holo finish is $2.99 a card in a Rookie Box, and nothing gets stolen faster than something shiny.
  • Bring two. Two cards are $21.99: one goes in the game and one goes to the person on it, so they can stop trying to steal it back.
  • No limit at your party? A MEGA card is 11 x 15.4 inches for $49.99, comes in a protective sleeve, and is very hard to hide under a chair.

Price and timing

One card is $17.99 in a magnetic display case, before tax. US standard shipping costs $5 below a $30 order and nothing on orders of $30 or more, so check whether your group's limit counts shipping. For a Christmas party, order by Monday, December 14 with standard shipping; it is expected by Wednesday, December 23.

Ready to make your own card?

Upload a photo, pick a template, and preview your custom card in about 60 seconds. Free to design.

  • Upload a photo
  • Pick a template
  • We print & ship

Questions

More questions

Is Dirty Santa the same as white elephant?

Yes. Dirty Santa, white elephant and Yankee Swap are the same gift-stealing game under different names. Dirty Santa is the name many Southern families use, and it usually comes with more stealing.

What is the funniest Dirty Santa gift?

A gift about someone in the room. A card of the cousin who always loses at cornhole, with "Games played: 300. Games won: 2" on the back, beats any novelty mug, and it fits in a stocking.

How many times can a gift be stolen in Dirty Santa?

Whatever the group agrees before the first gift is opened, usually two or three steals. After the last steal, the gift is frozen with whoever holds it. Agree on the number first, or the card of the host will change hands all night.

What is a good Dirty Santa gift for $20?

One custom card is $17.99 in a magnetic display case, before shipping and tax. US standard shipping is $5 on orders under $30, so check whether your group counts shipping toward the limit.

Can I make one in time for the party?

Designing takes a few minutes once you have the photo. Every order ships the next business day, and checkout shows the arrival window for each shipping option.