Holiday Gifts2 min read

What is a good white elephant gift under $25?

The Snapshot TeamMakers of custom trading cardsLast reviewed:

Quick answer

A custom trading card fits a $25 white elephant limit: one card in a magnetic display case is $17.99, or $22.99 with standard US shipping, before tax. Make it a card of someone the group knows, like the host or the office dog, and expect it to be stolen at least once.

Key takeaways

  1. One card with a magnetic display case is $17.99; standard US shipping adds $5 on orders under $30, for $22.99 before tax.
  2. It fits a $25 or $30 limit. If a $20 limit has to cover shipping, it does not fit.
  3. The best subject is someone, or some pet, the whole group knows.
  4. Order by Monday, December 14 with standard shipping for expected delivery by Wednesday, December 23.

Why it wins the steal round

A white elephant gift has two jobs: get a laugh when it is opened, and be worth stealing afterward. Most gifts under $25 manage one of the two. A trading card of the host, the boss or the office dog does both, because the joke is about someone in the room and the gift is a real printed card in a display case.

It also survives the game. Small, rigid and boxed, it gets passed around a circle better than a mug or a candle.

What fits under each price limit

Prices are before tax. Standard US shipping is $5 below a $30 order and free on orders of $30 or more.

  • Under $25: one card in a magnetic display case, $22.99 with standard shipping.
  • Under $30: a matching pair of cards, $21.99 plus $5 shipping, or $26.99.
  • Under $50: five cards in one box for $31.99, with free US standard shipping on orders of $30 or more.
  • Under $20 including shipping: a printed card does not fit. Save it for a gift without a cap.

Put the joke on the back

Keep the front looking like a real card: a good photo, a name, a position. Put the joke where the stats go. "Meetings survived: 1,204" or "Career naps: undefeated" lands better than a gag on the front, and the card still looks good on a desk in January.

  • The boss, as "Head Coach of the Fourth Quarter"
  • The office dog or the host's cat, with treat-based stats
  • Last year's white elephant winner, on a championship card

Getting it there before the party

For a party before Christmas, compare the arrival window at checkout with the party date. For Christmas week, order by Monday, December 14 with standard shipping; the card is expected by Wednesday, December 23. When available, Priority and Overnight orders placed before the same-day cut-off on a business day ship that same day.

Ready to make your own card?

Upload a photo, pick a template, and preview your custom card in about 60 seconds. Free to design.

  • Upload a photo
  • Pick a template
  • We print & ship

Questions

More questions

Is there a white elephant gift like this under $20?

The card itself is $17.99. Standard US shipping adds $5 on orders below $30, so the total is $22.99 before tax. If your group's $20 limit includes shipping, it does not fit; if the limit covers the gift alone, it does.

Is it okay to make a card of a coworker for a work party?

Keep it kind. Use a photo they would be happy to see printed, aim the joke at a habit everyone shares, and leave looks out of it. If in doubt, make the office dog the star.

What if the person who opens it does not know the subject?

Pick someone the whole room knows. A card of the host, the boss or a shared pet works for every guest; a card of your cousin only works at a family party.

Can I ship it straight to the party host?

Yes. Enter the host's address as the shipping address at checkout. There is no gift wrap or gift message, so ask the host to set the parcel aside unopened.