AllStar Artifacts alternatives: five other custom card makers, compared
- The Slab $39.99
- Holographic slab $44.99
- Cards without a slab from $17.99

Why look elsewhere
Why people look past AllStar Artifacts
Every card comes slabbed
Its pricing page lists two products, a Premium Slabbed card and a Holographic Slabbed card. There is no card without a case, no box of different cards and no poster-size card.[1]
The deals start at two cards
The extra 15% off and the free shipping both come with orders of two or more cards. For one card, the pricing page gives no shipping price.[1]
The prices are sale prices
The $39.95 slab is listed at $57 and the $49.95 holographic slab at $71, both marked 30% off. A sale can end, so confirm the total at checkout.[1]
No cards of professional athletes or teams
Its FAQ says it does not make cards of professional athletes or teams, only similar styles from your own photos.[2]
The alternatives
5 makers to weigh instead
1.Snapshot
See The SlabBest for: A slab you design yourself, or a card that needs no slab at all
- Price
- The Slab $39.99, $44.99 holographic; one card in a magnetic case $17.99; Bulk Box from $37.99
- Turnaround
- Ships next business day; delivery time depends on location
Where it wins
- A holographic slab for $44.99, against AllStar’s $49.95 ($4.96 less at Snapshot)
- Free US shipping on a single slab
- A serialized label (player, year, serial number) on every slab
- Cards without a slab, MEGA posters ($49.99) and team player packs
Check first
One holographic style, Cracked Ice, and the same price for every slab, with no multi-card discount.
2.RC Custom Cards
Snapshot vs RC Custom CardsBest for: An artist who prepares the design for you and texts a proof
- Price
- Custom Graded Card $38.99 sale (listed $70), $29.24 each at five; a card without a case $23.99
- Turnaround
- Proof by text within 48 hours of purchase; ships within 48 hours of approval
3.Bora Concepts
Snapshot vs Bora ConceptsBest for: A premium card its team designs from scratch, or a card of an athlete it works with
- Price
- From $50.99 with a top loader, $55.99 with a Bora Mag Case (sale prices, listed $95.99 and $110.99); athlete cards from $31.99
- Turnaround
- Production time not stated on the product page; shipping calculated at checkout
4.Iconix Prints
Snapshot vs Iconix PrintsBest for: A youth baseball or softball team buying trading packs
- Price
- $187 sale (listed $360) for 96 holographic cards per player, about $1.95 a card
- Turnaround
- Not listed; partner orders picked up at team meetings or shipped on request
5.CustomSportsCards.com
Snapshot vs CustomSportsCards.comBest for: A group order, a 4 x 5.5 inch card, or a PDF to print yourself
- Price
- Quoted: price depends on size, quantity, finish and format
- Turnaround
- Prints every Tuesday and Thursday and ships the next day
At a glance
One encased card at each maker
| Maker | One card | Holographic | Two or more | Free shipping | Who designs it |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Snapshot, The Slab | $39.99 | $44.99 | Same price per slab | US orders $30+, so one slab ships free | You, in the builder |
| AllStar Artifacts | $39.95 sale (listed $57) | $49.95 sale (listed $71) | Extra 15% off the order | Two or more cards | You, in its free design tool |
| RC Custom Cards | $38.99 sale (listed $70) | Finish upcharge not shown | 10% off at two, up to 25% off at five | Orders over $70 | An artist, proofed by text |
| Bora Concepts | $50.99 sale with a top loader (listed $95.99) | Described as refractor-style | Bulk orders by email | Calculated at checkout | Bora’s team, from scratch |
Competitor prices are as listed on the date in the sources below, sale prices included. Shipping and tax are extra where not free.
Sources for AllStar Artifacts
- [1] AllStar Artifacts pricing, checked November 21, 2026
- [2] AllStar Artifacts home page, checked November 21, 2026
Sources for RC Custom Cards
- [1] RC custom card, checked November 21, 2026
- [2] RC custom graded card, checked November 21, 2026
- [3] RC Custom Cards home page, checked November 21, 2026
Sources for Bora Concepts
- [1] Bora custom trading card, checked November 21, 2026
- [2] Bora home page, checked November 21, 2026
- [3] Bora refund policy, checked November 21, 2026
Sources for Iconix Prints
- [1] Iconix All-Star Package, checked November 21, 2026
- [2] Iconix Prints home page, checked November 21, 2026
- [3] Iconix card foils, checked November 21, 2026
Sources for CustomSportsCards.com
- [1] CustomSportsCards.com FAQs, checked November 21, 2026
- [2] CustomSportsCards.com price guide, checked November 21, 2026
"Can't say enough good things!!! Cards were flawless....easy to create...KIDS flipped out for them. Fast print and ship. I will probably do this for my flag football boys every year!!! Priced right too."
— Cody P. · 4 weeks ago"Snap Shots delivers on great looking cards, let your imagination create authentic true 1/1 cards of your kids and favorite players! I did 3 and they look like they belong right up on the shelf with my other slabs. I highly recommend!"
— Josh L. · 3 weeks ago"We had my son’s senior pictures taken at Target field so I wanted to put those images on a baseball card to give out at his graduation party! I had so much fun creating them on the website! I ordered them on a Wednesday night and they were at my door that Saturday! Very quick! I couldn’t wait to open them! They are awesome! Better than I could have ever imagined! The quality is well worth the money! Amazing job! Will definitely recommend to anyone looking for a unique way to capture a forever memory!"
— Greg S. · 6 months ago"Just order cards here and be amazed. The product is so good and customer service treats you like a million bucks. I couldn't be happier with what I received and will be a return customer very soon!"
— HeHate M. · last week"I created a few AI cards for my kids. I started collecting back on February and the boys love the Kaboom cards. My daughter loves princesses so I made her a Disney card through AI. I looked for a company to actually make the card and found Snapshots. Very easy to use, very fast, excellent price. They actually called me to verify some of the information on the picture and offered to make any changes. I received them very quickly. I rarely leave reviews, but I felt this company deserved to hear that they are doing it right and I will definitely be using them again very soon."
— jimmy P. · 4 months ago"Love this company. Custom cards, quality card stock, good price. Great for family gifts or your own custom created card collection."
— Colt A. · today"The order came in within a week and they look amazing…Thank you very much!"
— Freddy M. · today"great!"
— Jordan A. · yesterday"I ordered my son a football card 4 days before his first playoff game, I was wanting to give it to him after the game as a gift. Snapshot delivered! Praise the Lord! So fast! The quality was absolutely amazing, I was blown away by it. It was so much more than I was hoping for! Thank you Snapshot. If I had the money I would have ordered my other son one. Amazing, I highly recommend Snapshot, stay away from other companies they will not measure up to the quality or customer service you get here!"
— Triple_Decker_Ministry · 4 days agoReviews from Google
What is the closest alternative to AllStar Artifacts?
For the same kind of product, a custom card sealed in a hard case: The Slab at Snapshot ($39.99, $44.99 holographic, with a serialized label) or RC Custom Cards’ Custom Graded Card ($38.99 sale, listed $70). AllStar adds a topper certificate above the card.
Is there a less expensive alternative to AllStar Artifacts?
For one standard slab, RC’s $38.99 sale price is $0.96 under AllStar’s $39.95, and The Slab at $39.99 is about the same price. For one holographic slab, The Slab is $44.99 against $49.95. More slabs change the order: two standard slabs are about $67.92 at AllStar, $70.18 at RC and $79.98 at Snapshot; five are about $169.79, $146.20 and $199.95.
Is AllStar Artifacts legit?
This page does not review AllStar Artifacts, and we have not ordered from it. Its own pages state its prices, a money back guarantee, a Los Angeles base, and that orders are printed and shipped within 48 hours (up to 72 on weekends). Read independent reviews before you order from any maker, us included.
Can I get a custom card without a slab?
Yes, at Snapshot: one card in a magnetic display case is $17.99, a Rookie Box holds up to 18 different cards for $49.99, and a Bulk Box of identical cards starts at $37.99. RC Custom Cards sells a card without a case for $23.99. AllStar’s pricing page lists slabbed cards only.
Which alternative suits a team?
Snapshot prices team orders up front: team player packs are $33.99 each through one team link, and Bulk Boxes start at $37.99. Iconix Prints sells 96-card holographic packages for baseball and softball players at $187 on sale, and CustomSportsCards.com quotes group orders.
Is a slabbed custom card professionally graded?
No. The Slab, AllStar’s slab and RC’s graded-style case each hold a card in a rigid case. None of them is a third-party grade.
Keep comparing
Other comparisons and our products
Design your card and see it first.
Pick a template, add your photo and the details, and review the finished card before you order.
