What the faster options are
Standard US shipping travels by USPS. The faster tiers are UPS services, and they appear at checkout once you enter a US address. Each is priced from the live carrier rate for that address plus handling, presented as a single price rather than a rate and a fee.
Expedited services are outside the $30 free-shipping rule, which applies only to standard.
How to choose
Every option at checkout shows an estimated arrival window. Compare the windows to your date and pick the cheapest service whose latest arrival date lands in time. If standard already fits, there is no reason to pay for more.
What speed does not change
A faster shipping service does not change what you get: the same card stock, the same magnetic display case with a Rookie Box, the same packaging. It changes only how the parcel travels.
Expedited services can be paused at busy times. If one is unavailable, checkout simply will not offer it, and an order placed with a paused service is refused rather than quietly downgraded.
Outside the US
International destinations get a standard and an express option, both priced from live rates. Puerto Rico is offered the same pair on its own lane.